” I have to pay tribute to my brother Philippe Mezhrahid, a surgeon, fan of technology and a storyteller …
This is his narrative and it shows in one hand the evolution of techniques and practices in the medical sector and on the other hand the collaboration between Man and Machine. This is a first training course on the robot Da-Vinci SI then XI, an introduction that validates a third of the robotics Diploma. Here is the story:
I looked at the group around me, and as the only senior, I felt a little bit uncomfortable. I was surrounded by young people who have spent their time killing people on the internet, but as my kids have taught me that it did not stop them from being successful at studies.
The head of the clinic rode on the robot being installed, while two young surgeons (and geeks) handled the joysticks like I handle a scalpel. Will this generational exchange benefit all of us? Only time will tell. However, the senior folks will still have to be in leadership roles.
Within the building entirely dedicated to the Nancy School of Surgery and led by Dr. Tran, we discovered:
During the internship, I discovered parallel skills, and in particular, the wording and formulation of instructions through the art of debriefing, and analysis of incidents and crash.
In the introduction, Jacques Huber presented the diploma of robotics and the need for expert training in this demanding technology, history, Genesis, creation of the certification after 6 days of immersion, and then adaptation by shorter thirds modules, more adapted to the rhythm of surgeons, and concluded with the delivery of the robotic diploma for one-third of the module.
A slide that retained my attention – that of Lord ARA DARZI (2000) which recorded the objective – the gesture of the expert, faster, economical, direct, than that of the beginner, or the senior. Objective feedback is possible:
“The brain learns through the TEST-ERROR-CORRECTION cycle”.
The 80’s dogma of the daily loss of neurons has since been canceled and replaced by the concept of NEUROPLASTICITY OF BRAIN.
Any new learning remains possible and at any time. We refer to recent jurisprudence of robotic surgery, rather positional aftereffect due to the length of an intervention (around 7 h 00) without verification of the state of the patient during the procedure.
“Never the first time …”
In the presentation by Jean Luc Moreau, it was indicated that your first time can never be on a patient. The learning has to be by simulation as described by HAS 2012. It was, therefore, necessary to perform surgery virtually by practicing with MIMIC and DV trainer simulators, and then practicing on animal or corpses, before working with the patient.
Let’s go and practice with Jean Pierre and Erwan. The “TRANSFORMER” was stored at the bottom of the room, unmoved, disconnected, debonair, blind, silent, and harmless – at least for now. We started with the docking of the endoscope, calibration, adjustment of focus, markings and other routines. “He can see …”
“Your turn “.
Paralyzed, here is how to activate the arms, locate the mobility buttons, move the kneecaps, manipulate the arms, control the indicator lights, interpret alarms, more clicks, confirmation beeps …” He can move… “. And becomes sacred chatter…
Be careful not to pinch your fingers. 100 kgs of pressure between each arm, “we usually remember … “.
“He must …” touch the patient, Jean Pierre showed the sterile field of the arms, described the approach and the positioning of the robot by aeronautical indications.
“Do the two! …..”
“Do the two and do not forget to communicate as accurately as possible”. Orders are imprecise and often confused. I do not remember any communication course in my curriculum …, a secure communication system must be set up. “There is no need to reinvent the wheel, you can transpose aeronautical jargon for example … here are some instructions …”
“Think of speaking this way to your surgical aid”. And, it’s much more precise. Jean-Pierre practices, decomposes the movements of the hands, the positioning of the thumb-index to secure the trocar and then snaps clamps, scalpel, and scissors. Mnemonic metaphors, scripts and tricks…
“Your turn!”. Finally, he passed us the leash of the beast.
“Like a praying mantis …”
“Do not forget the robot works back and forth like a praying mantis; be gentle especially for the patient …”
The robot was ready to go to simulators and consoles. Two by two, each of us was using the joystick. MIMIC simulators allowed us virtual exercises. The DV trainer simulator had the immense advantage of coupling the robot console with a laparoscopic trainer and of working with a total of four hands, two of the operator, and two of the helper.
Nicolas Huber came to supervise … “You should … do it like this … I had this type of problem once … it reminds me of this situation” … rich in scripts and anecdotes that lock the memory.
The virtual simulation exercises were sanctioned by the implacable evaluations of the computer and the trainers only allowed you to proceed to the next exercise if you succeeded in the current exercise by obtaining 85% two consecutive times.
We manipulated real objects and we did real sutures, we did not have to steal the plastic hoses and break the sutures. “And for the feedback of force?”; “Not necessary” replied Jacques Huber, “obviously micro-surgeons who worked with a wire with a thickness of 10 have already understood this point… It is easy to feel the resistance of a cloth or a wire”.
Jean-Pierre went on and began snickering at us: “When you manipulate small plastic bits if you tighten them too strong, they escape and become excellent projectiles … You can eliminate a participant and have more spaces for training … But it is better to avoid such a situation … So, treat them delicately …”
The training was good and progress was rapid.
At the end of the afternoon, Dr. Tran showed us his kingdom of simulators, mannequins, pelvic trainer, surgical microscope, video consoles…
It seems easy but what will it stay 4 weeks later? It will be necessary to recover quickly and validate the rest of the module. and practice, practice ….
Anyway, we definitively enter a new era for medical and surgical activities where the cobotic will drive the new technics.
About Jacques Mezhrahid
Jacques contributes to install a new way of Innovation, pushing a mindset based on demonstrating the innovation added value for Sogeti and our clients as well. After 10 years on IT side, Jacques is back on OT challenges and Industry4.0 within Sogeti High Tech organization
More on Jacques Mezhrahid.